The Best Pizza in Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh is the home of the Steelers, a boatload of bridges (446 of ’em, to be exact), and some especially delicious pizza.

That’s right – delicious pizza. Pittsburgh might not draw as much acclaim for its pies as, say, Philly, but there are quality shops for both locals and out-of-towners to discover.

Here’s where you can get the best pizza in the ‘Burgh:

Brick N’ Mortar

Hawaiian pizza lovers can catch a wave of flavor with Brick N’ Mortar’s Maui Wowie pie – an elevated take on the classic. Bacon, ham, capicola, pineapple, scallion, brick cheese, Asiago, and a charred chili pepper aioli drizzle top this bold pizza, which could convert even the most ardent of pineapple pizza haters. Alternatively, for some serious heat, there’s the Diavolo Pizza, with banana peppers, red onions, roasted peppers, Romano, basil, and BnM’s own house made crumbled hot sausage.

Sunset Pizza & Grille

There aren’t many shops that can offer quality pizza and deliciously buttery baklava, but Sunset Pizza & Grille in Carnegie does just that. We’re proponents of Sunset in part because of its versatility. Here, you can get a Meat Medley pizza with a side of jumbo wings on one night, then order again the next night for a Turkish feast complete with Borek and Cacik.  

Angelo’s Pizzeria  

Angelo’s Pizzeria serves up phenomenal pies in the heart of Pittsburgh’s Little Italy. Using fresh ingredients and the techniques passed down to him by his father, Master Pizzero Joe Posteraro aims to deliver Italian history and perfect bites with his offerings, including thin-crust and Sicilian pies. Also, in the Pittsburgh tradition, Angelo’s has a fantastic hoagie to satisfy every craving. 

Genoa Pizza

Genoa brings Pittsburgh an old school experience with new school takes on pizza, including a unique selection of calzones. Here, you’ll find the standard options (meatball calzones) and with Saturday/Sunday football go-tos (buffalo chicken), plus their Seafood Calzone, which packs shrimp, crab meat, garlic, and white sauce all into one pizza pocket. 

Pizza Parma 

Pittsburgh Pizza Parma

If this is your first rodeo at Pizza Parma, we might suggest starting with the Steak Rodeo pizza, which piles hot peppers, onions, mushrooms, fresh garlic, tomatoes, buffalo fries, mozzarella, provolone, romato, and sirloin steak on top of one delicious pie.  Or, if you’re feeling the buffalo fries but want a bit more in the way of ferocity, go for the Krunk Chicken pizza, with tomatoes, green peppers, fresh garlic, grilled chicken, and homemade tiger sauce, a blend of buffalo and ranch. 

Mario’s Pizza

Sure, you could just get one or two of Mario’s pies and call it a day, but it wouldn’t be a complete meal without Mario’s Boneless Wing Dings, which can be tossed in your choice of sauce, including BBQ, Garlic, Honey BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, and Buffalo. Or, to keep things a bit less messy but equally tasty, get ‘em coated in Mario’s Wing Dust. 

Picasso’s Pizza

With homemade dough and bread baked on a daily basis, Picasso’s prides itself on making every meal a masterpiece. 

Fiori’s Pizzaria

With locations in Brookline and McMurray, Pennsylvania, Fiori’s is a longstanding no-frills shop offering thin and ultra-cheesy slices, plus crispy calzones jam-packed with ricotta and provolone.

King Crust

Kings Crust Pizza Pittsburgh

If you come for the King, you best not miss their doughy pepperoni pie, which could satisfy the Steelers’ entire offensive line. 

Pizza Americana

For a while, this spot in Carnegie, PA was a bit of a revolving door for restaurants. That was until a few years ago, when Pizza Americana brought its cheese-laden New York and Sicilian pies to the neighborhood. There are tons of toppings available here, but the Spinach/Tomato/Feta combo is among its most popular.

Slice On Broadway

Slice on Broadway

If you’ve never had an Capricciosa pizza before, Slice On Broadway would be a great place to start – prosciutto, artichoke hearts, black olives, mushrooms, and tomato sauce top this Italian classic that can be hard to find here in the States. 

Pizza Taglio

With Neapolitan influence and a BYOB policy, Pizza Taglio is a fave in the East Liberty neighborhood. 

Driftwood Oven

Pittsburgh Driftwood Pizza Pies

Sourdough crusts and ethically sourced produce make these pizzas among the most sought after in Pittsburgh. Pro tip: Opt for one of the rotating pies on the menu to capture some of the season’s best produce and flavors on your plate. In the fall, that means 16-inch pies with red kale, pork shoulder braised in apple cider, and more. 

Leave a Reply