Staff Picks: Our NYC Favorites

Bucket list-worthy pizza from people who really love pizza.

Sofia Pizza Shoppe, Midtown East
Classica Pizza

“Sofia makes a classic slice that is consistently excellent and perfectly portioned. Matt and Tom always keep it real.  Every time I’m in the area, I try to make it a point to stop in and catch up!”

–Cody, Product Development

Pizza Italia, Chelsea
Grandma Pie

“Every time I get asked for pizza recommendations, I always call Pizza Italia ‘the best kept secret in NYC.’ It’s a cheesy thing to say, but it’s true – their Grandma slice is incredible.”

–Madison, Social Media

Carmine’s Pizza Factory, Jersey City
Buffalo Wing Chicken Pizza

“Growing up in Jersey, I had access to a lot of great pizza. But I always come back to Carmine’s. I love everything from their family vibes to authentic pies.”

–Jess, Design

Patricia’s of Tremont, The Bronx
Brick Oven Margherita

“The food is just awesome, but what really makes it is that the people smile when they come to my door. That’s so rare here.”

-Caleb, Product

View this post on Instagram

Come join us for our famous #brickovenpizza

A post shared by Patricia's Of Tremont (@patricia_of_tremont) on

Joe and Pat’s, Staten Island
Vodka Pizza

“The simpler the food, the more difficult the execution. That’s why this pizza shines. You can really taste the quality as you’re scarfing it down.”

–Samantha, Sales

Leave a Reply